Will I Regret Being Childfree? What the Research Actually Says

Let me tell you about the question that’s supposed to haunt childfree women: “But won’t you regret it?”

It usually comes right after someone finds out you don’t have kids and don’t want them. Sometimes it’s phrased as concern. Sometimes it’s smug certainty. Always, it’s presented as if they know something about your future that you somehow can’t see.

“You’ll regret it when you’re older.” “Who will take care of you when you’re old?” “You’ll change your mind.” “It’s different when they’re your own.”

If you’ve been hearing these warnings for years, you’re probably still waiting for that regret to show up.

Spoiler alert: for most childfree people, it doesn’t. And according to actual research (not just opinions from people who can’t imagine life without kids), that’s completely normal.

The Research That Might Surprise You

Here’s what the data actually shows about childfree regret: it’s far less common than people assume.

A study published in PLOS ONE by researchers at Michigan State University found that older childfree adults don’t experience more life regret than older parents. In fact, when researchers compared adults age 70 and older, there was no significant difference in life satisfaction or regret between childfree people and parents.

Let me repeat that: childfree people in their 70s are just as satisfied with their lives as parents in their 70s.

Professor Jennifer Watling Neal, who led the research, put it plainly: “Childfree people, especially women, are often told they’ll be dissatisfied with life or regret their decision later. We didn’t see any difference between childfree people and parents. This suggests that childfree people are similar to others in terms of life satisfaction and often don’t regret their decision later.”

Another study examined regret and psychological wellbeing among voluntarily childless women, involuntarily childless women, and mothers. The findings? Voluntarily childless women showed higher levels of overall wellbeing compared to involuntarily childless women, rated themselves as more autonomous with greater environmental mastery, and were less likely to have child-related regret.

Think about what that means. Women who actively chose not to have children reported better wellbeing than women who wanted children but couldn’t have them. The regret wasn’t in the choice itself—it was in not having the choice.

What People Actually Regret

Here’s something that doesn’t get talked about enough: plenty of parents have regrets too.

According to data from the Institute for Family Studies, when asked if they wished they’d had fewer children, 14% of people with children agreed. That’s 10% of all adults who either regret having kids or wish they’d had fewer.

Meanwhile, 24% of people with children said they wished they’d had more children. And 37% of all adults—the largest group—wish they had more children whether they’re currently parents or not.

So let’s do the math: More people regret not having enough children than regret having children at all. But neither number is the majority. Most people—whether childfree or parents—are content with their choices.

The real story here isn’t about regret. It’s about whether your decision was intentional and aligned with what you actually wanted for your life.

The Difference Between Choosing and Defaulting

Research by marriage and family therapist Ann Davidman, who has run parenthood clarity courses for 30 years, found something crucial: clarity about a decision allows people to live without regret.

It’s not about making the “right” choice between having kids or not having them. It’s about making a conscious, considered choice rather than sleepwalking into either option.

As Davidman explains, “Deciding to have children, or not, doesn’t inoculate you against regret. It’s still up to you to figure out how to have a fulfilling life.”

This is the key. It’s not just about passively not having kids. It’s about actively deciding. Thinking about what you want your life to look like. Considering what kind of parent you’d be if you had kids. Weighing your values, your capacity, your desires.

And then choosing accordingly. Whether that’s parenthood or a childfree life, what matters is that it’s an intentional choice, not a default.

Why People Assume You’ll Regret It

So if the research shows most childfree people don’t regret their decision, why does everyone keep insisting they will?

Part of it is projection. As researcher Malin Ekelund found in her study on perceptions of childfree people, those who judge childfree people most harshly are often people who haven’t had kids yet but plan to.

Ekelund suggests this might be a “motivational explanation”—that people who feel threatened by the option to not have children may question the validity of their own choices. If you’ve built your life around the assumption that you’ll have kids someday, meeting someone who consciously chose not to can feel destabilizing.

It’s easier to dismiss that person as deluded or destined for regret than to sit with the discomfort that maybe, just maybe, parenthood isn’t the only path to a fulfilling life.

There’s also the issue of social norms. As psychologist Zachary Neal points out, the expectation to become parents—or at least to want children—is almost universal. “A person who says ‘I don’t want to have children’ is violating a norm, and not just any norm but a very strongly held norm that’s been held for millennia.”

When you violate deeply held social norms, people get uncomfortable. And one way they deal with that discomfort is by insisting you must be wrong, that you’ll see the error of your ways eventually, that you’ll regret your choice.

What Regret Actually Looks Like

Here’s what people need to understand: childfree people aren’t immune to moments of wondering “what if?”

Just like parents sometimes look at their childfree friends having brunch and sleeping in and think “What would my life be like if I didn’t have kids?”, childfree people occasionally wonder what parenthood would have been like.

As journalist Gina Rushton notes in her book The Parenthood Dilemma, “We also all know mums who some days just want to be out with their friends having martinis, and can’t—that doesn’t mean they don’t love their children, or regret them.”

Wondering isn’t the same as regretting. Curiosity about the path not taken is not the same as wishing you’d taken it.

Childfree people have moments where they wonder what kind of parent they would have been. What their kid might have looked like. What it would feel like to have that bond.

But those fleeting moments of curiosity don’t negate the deep certainty about the choice. They don’t make people wish they’d chosen differently. They’re just… thoughts. Passing curiosities about an alternate reality that isn’t theirs.

The Stories From People Living It

The BuzzFeed article that collected stories from 32 childfree people over 40 is full of perspectives that challenge the regret narrative.

One 66-year-old woman who’s been married for 37 years said: “I never had a minute of regret. I knew I didn’t want to have children when I was 15… I’d rather regret not having kids than regret having one.”

A 57-year-old childfree woman shared: “I sincerely believe that I would have been a piss-poor mother… If I had had children, I would have been driven to suicide or homicide.”

Another person in their 60s reflected: “Sometimes I regret not having children but would still make the choice to be childless if we had it to do over. The financial benefits are huge, and you have the freedom to travel and make radical life changes without worrying about adverse effects on the children.”

These aren’t people drowning in regret. They’re people living intentional lives, aware of trade-offs, and content with their choices.

The “Who Will Take Care of You” Argument

Let’s address the elephant in the room: the assumption that you need kids to care for you in old age.

First, as one childfree person brilliantly put it in the BuzzFeed piece: “When people ask, ‘Who will take care of you when you’re old?’ I tell them that when I’m 75, I will adopt a 40-year-old.”

But more seriously, this argument is deeply flawed for several reasons.

One person shared: “My wife worked at a nursing home for years. For years, she saw that more than 95% of old people have families who never visit until they die, and then everyone wants a piece of the pie. This is when I learned that the whole ‘Well, who is going to visit you or take care of you when you’re older?’ line is complete bullshit.”

Having children doesn’t guarantee they’ll take care of you. It doesn’t guarantee they’ll visit you. It doesn’t guarantee they’ll live nearby or have the capacity to help even if they want to.

And more importantly: having children so they’ll take care of you later is a terrible reason to have children. It’s treating potential human beings as an insurance policy, not as autonomous people who will have their own lives, priorities, and limitations.

As discussed in the article on aging without kids, building a support system for aging doesn’t require biological children. It requires intentional planning, genuine relationships, and financial preparation.

The Climate Reality Nobody Wants to Talk About

It would be incomplete not to mention what’s increasingly driving childfree decisions: the climate crisis.

A systematic review published in PLOS Climate found four main climate-related concerns cited in reproductive decision-making: uncertainty about an unborn child’s future, the ecological impact of reproduction, meeting family subsistence needs, and contributing to environmental activism.

When climate scientists—the people who study this professionally—were surveyed, one-fifth of female climate scientists and 7% of males had chosen to have no children or fewer children due to climate concerns.

As journalist Elle Hunt writes in The Guardian, “Because the climate crisis is so obvious, it’s very easy to hang your hat on it.” But it’s also a very real factor that can’t be dismissed.

Climate concerns are part of many childfree decisions. It’s hard to ignore the world being left for future generations. And it’s entirely valid to factor that into reproductive choices.

What Makes a Life Meaningful

Here’s what the regret conversation is really about: the fear that without children, life won’t have meaning.

But as the research and lived experiences show, meaning doesn’t come from one single source. It comes from relationships, work, creativity, community, contribution, growth, connection.

One childfree person in their 60s said it perfectly: “Life is meaningful to us because we’ve stayed involved enough with family, friends, pets, and volunteer work to be ‘useful.’ We’ve never felt the need to have an extra source of meaning; there’s more than enough to do in the world right now.”

Another reflected: “Instead of having kids, we participated in helping those already here in a number of ways.”

As explored in the article on mom life or me life, choosing not to have children isn’t choosing emptiness. It’s choosing to direct your energy, love, and resources differently.

Life has meaning when you build it to have meaning. Through work that matters. Through relationships you’ve nurtured. Through communities you’ve created or joined. Through contributions you make to the world.

None of that requires children. All of it requires intention.

The Freedom to Choose (And Be Supported In It)

The growing childfree population—now over 20% of adults in some studies—tells us something important: more people are questioning the default script.

And that’s a good thing. Not because parenthood is bad, but because choosing is better than defaulting.

Whether you choose to have kids or choose not to, that choice deserves to be respected. It deserves to be made consciously, with full awareness of what you’re choosing and what you’re not.

What doesn’t help anyone is the constant questioning, the predictions of regret, the insistence that there’s only one path to a fulfilling life.

The research is clear: childfree people are just as satisfied with their lives as parents. The regret rates are similar. The wellbeing is similar. The only real difference is the path taken to get there.

The Bottom Line on Childfree Regret

The question isn’t whether you’ll regret being childfree. The question is whether you’re living a life that’s true to who you are and what you want.

Make that decision consciously. Consider it fully. Be honest with yourself about what you want and don’t want.

And then trust yourself. Whether you choose parenthood or a childfree life, own that choice. Build a life around it that feels meaningful and fulfilling.

Answer that honestly, and the regret takes care of itself.

If you’re childfree by choice and navigating a world that still questions that decision, know this: you’re not broken. You’re not selfish. You’re not going to wake up at 70 drowning in regret.

You’re just living a different kind of life. And as the research shows, that life can be just as fulfilling, just as meaningful, and just as satisfying as any other.

---

You Don’t Have to Navigate This Alone

Choosing to be childfree in a world that still expects motherhood from women can feel isolating. But here’s the good news: you’re not alone, and you don’t have to defend your choice.

Let’s talk about where you are in your journey. Whether you’re still deciding, dealing with judgment from others, or just need someone who gets it—therapy can help. No pressure, no judgment, just real conversation.

Book your free consultation here